How to Stop Overmedicalizing Mental Health

Listen to this story.
Enjoy more audio and podcasts iOS system or Android.

Your browser does not support

For a place The UK is known for its conservative stoicism, but it has a very open attitude towards mental health. Britons are more likely than people in other wealthy countries to think mental illness is a disease like any other. Only Swedes are more accepting of the idea that a history of mental health problems should not disqualify someone from holding public office. Everyone from the Princess of Wales to Opposition Leader Sir Keir Starmer has championed the importance of good mental health; employers are preaching the gospel of happiness. British people were once encouraged to hide their feelings. They are now urged to seek support.

Many rich countries have been grappling with rising rates of self-reported mental health problems, particularly since the covid-19 pandemic. But the UK figures are shocking. Around 4.5 million people in the UK came into contact with mental health services in 2021-22, an increase of almost 1 million in five years. No other European country has seen such a growth in the use of antidepressants over the past decade. National Health Service (National Health Service)NHS) A 2023 survey found that one in five young people aged 8 to 16 in England are likely to have a mental disorder, compared with one in eight in 2017. Among 17- to 19-year-olds, the number rises from one in 10. to a quarter. The number of people losing their job due to mental health issues increased by a third between 2019 and 2023.

Happily, people don’t feel like they have to bottle things up, and the pain of mental illness is real. Awareness of mental health reduces the stigma of certain conditions and reveals the unmet needs of many Britons. But awareness also takes its toll.

Despite their best intentions, campaigns to raise awareness have led some people to conflate normal reactions to life’s difficulties with mental health disorders. Specialty treatments can create incentives for people to seek diagnosis and treat problems unnecessarily. The need to treat those with less severe disease competes with the need to care for those with the most severe disease.

First, mental health has become a catch-all term. The percentage of people who say they have a disease is definitely a red flag. Some 57% of university students claim to have mental health problems; more than three-quarters of parents of school-age children sought assistance or advice about their children’s mental health issues in 2021-22. In surveys, Britons are increasingly describing grief and stress as mental illnesses, redefining the understanding of illness. There are no objective biomarkers for most conditions, so self-reported symptoms figure prominently in official statistics and the diagnostic process.

People have an incentive to label minor pain as a disease. More than a quarter of 16 and 18-year-olds in UK schools were given extra time to sit official exams in 2022 due to a medical condition. Evidence of mental health problems can unlock benefits.Certification does not have to come from NHS Doctor: Available in many private clinics. Companies may prefer to call stress a disease rather than acknowledge the consequences of poor working conditions (the World Health Organization suggests that good management is the best way to protect mental health in the workplace). Rates of depression diagnoses are highest among England’s poorest people, but the government may be more willing to prescribe antidepressants than try to tackle poverty.

Patients may not benefit from medical treatment of mild pain. A study of mindfulness courses in 84 UK schools found that regular teaching was also beneficial to mental health. But the huge harm of overdiagnosis is to those who need help most.

this NHSIn theory, patients can be triaged as needed. In reality, chronically understaffed and poorly organized services are struggling to cope with growing demand. The number of young people coming into contact with mental health services has increased by more than three and a half times the number of child and adolescent psychiatry practitioners. The overall mental health workforce growth of 22% in the five years to 2021-22 will never be matched by a 44% increase in all patient referrals. At least 1.8 million people are waiting for mental health treatment.

Increased demand is driving employees into private practice.Clinicians are exhausted from dealing with the most severe cases NHS You can earn up to $US1,000 ($1,265) per case for ADHD evaluation. NHS Compared with a decade ago, the number of consultant psychiatrists in the United States has increased by only 6%, while the number of emergency medicine consultants has increased by 86%. The police gathered some clues. Police officers in the UK spend around 1 million hours a year in accident and emergency departments treating people with mental illness, but this is not therapy. Despite growing awareness of mental health conditions, outcomes for people with serious mental illnesses such as bipolar disorder and schizophrenia are worsening; they die 15 to 20 years earlier than others, a gap that has widened during COVID-19 – 19) The outbreak was already expanding and has been exacerbated by COVID-19.

Rethinking the UK’s approach to mental health requires some changes. More money should be invested in research so that individuals are treated appropriately; mental illness takes up 9% of the UK health budget but 6% of medical research funding. Social causes of mental illness should also receive more attention. Earlier this year, the government shelved an ambitious plan to examine the underlying context of mental disorders, from poverty to isolation. The program should be reinstated. More time and energy should be devoted to those most in need; reforming the Mental Health Act, a punitive law that still criminalizes people with mental illness, would be a start.

Causes and effects

Most importantly, the UK needs to avoid mass medical treatment of mild suffering. Introducing people into an overstretched health care system has predictable effects. All pain should be taken seriously, but a diagnosis isn’t always in someone’s best interest; a recent study found that when volunteers learned to suppress negative thoughts, they were happier. The UK is becoming more compassionate towards mental health. It also needs to become more thoughtful.

Subscribers only: To learn how we design our weekly covers, sign up for our weekly cover stories newsletter.

#Stop #Overmedicalizing #Mental #Health
Image Source : www.economist.com

Leave a Comment